Petitions and applications docketed on November 04, 2026
type Caption Docket No Court Below Petitioner's Counsel Counsel's Address Recent Filings QP
paid The Retail Property Trust

v.

Nassau County Department of Assessment

26-588 Second Circuit, No. 25-907

Judgment: August 06, 2026

James T. Smith Blank Rome LLP One Logan Square 130 North 18th Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presented1

QUESTIONS PRESENTED To raise revenue, a local government transformed a rarely-enforced $500 fine into a multimillion-dollar fine under the guise of seeking a better compliance rate and more accurate assessment data for property owners. The result was the issuance of a $4.8 million fine to Petitioner without any prior notice or opportunity to challenge it. In upholding the Constitutionality of the fine, the Second Cuircuit’s decision below ruled on two important Constitutional questions in a manner conflicting with this Court’s precedent and the decisions of multiple Circuit Courts. The questions presented are: Whether, when determining if a civil fine violates the Excessive Fines Clause under United States uv. Bajakajian, a court may evaluate the gravity of the underlying offense purely in the abstract (as the Second Circuit did below), or must instead consider the gravity of the specific defendant’s conduct (as six other Circuit Courts have held)? Whether the availability of a state remedy entirely forecloses a procedural due process claim under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 (as the Second Circuit held below), or whether, consistent with this Court’s decisions in Zinermon v. Burch and Knick v. Township of Scott, a plaintiff challenging an official government action may bring a procedural due process claim irrespective of available state remedies (as four other Circuit Courts have held)?

paid Lee M. Zeldin, Administrator, Environmental Protection Agency

v.

Climate United Fund

26-589 District of Columbia Circuit, No. 25-5122, 25-5123

Judgment: August 04, 2026

D. John Sauer Solicitor General United States Department of Justice 950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20530-0001 [Petition] NA
paid Brian Federico

v.

United States

26-590 Ninth Circuit, No. 24-7089

Judgment: June 30, 2026

Benjamin Lee Coleman Benjamin L. Coleman Law PC 1350 Columbia Street Suite 600 San Diego, CA 92101 [Petition] NA
ifp Tyaiwan Ousley

v.

Florida

26-6052 District Court of Appeal of Florida, Fourth District, No. 4D2025-2288

Judgment: June 10, 2026

Benjamin Nathaniel Paley Office of the Public Defender 421 3rd Street West Palm Beach, FL 33401 [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presentedQUESTION PRESENTED Whether Williams v. Florida, 399 U.S. 78 (1970), should be overturned and the right to a twelve-person jury restored. Because the Court has granted certiorari in a case that raises the same question presented here, see Kian v. Florida, No. 25-6623, 2026 WL 1718018 (U.S. June 15, 2026), the Court should hold this case in abeyance until it issues its decision in Kian. i
ifp David Wayne DePape

v.

United States

26-6053 Ninth Circuit, No. 24-3458

Judgment: —

Todd Michael Borden Office of the Federal Public Defender 450 Golden Gate Ave. Room 19-6884 San Francisco, CA 94102 [Main Document] [Lower Court Orders/Opinions] [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presentedQUESTION PRESENTED

Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 35(a) permits a district court, within 14 days after sentencing, to “correct a sentence that resulted from arithmetical, technical, or other clear error.” Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 32(1)(4)(A)(1), in turn, requires the court to address the defendant personally and permit him to speak before imposing the sentence.

The question presented 1s:

Whether Rule 35(a) authorizes a district court to vacate an otherwise lawful sentence 1t has announced and to conduct a new discretionary sentencing proceeding, over the defendant’s objection, to cure its failure to afford the defendant an opportunity to allocute under Rule 32()(4)(A)(ii).

1

ifp Brennan James Comeaux

v.

United States

26-6054 Fifth Circuit, No. 24-30307

Judgment: June 18, 2026

Dustin Talbot Federal Public Defender 102 Versailles Blvd. Ste. 816 Lafayette, LA 70501 [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presentedQUESTION PRESENTED Whether a court may uphold the National Firearms Act’s requirement that a person obtain federal approval before making a silencer and register it, by presuming the requirement constitutional under footnote 9 of New York State Rifle & Pistol Association, Inc. v. Bruen, 597 U.S. 1 (2022), unless the challenger shows that it has been put toward abusive ends, without requiring the government to show that the requirement 1s consistent with the Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation? 1
ifp Charles Roy

v.

United States

26-6055 Fifth Circuit, No. 25-30285

Judgment: July 01, 2026

Samantha Jean Kuhn Federal Public Defender’s Office 500 Poydras Street, Suite 318 New Orleans, LA 70130 [Main Document] [Lower Court Orders/Opinions] [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presentedQUESTION PRESENTED Whether, under the categorical approach, a defendant must always produce an actual case to demonstrate a state statute’s overbreadth, even when the state statute is facially broader than the federal standard. ! 1 This case presents the same question raised in United States v. Augillard, No. 26-476, which is currently pending review by the Court (petition filed October 6, 2026). u
ifp Larry Inoa

v.

Pamela Casey O’Brien

26-6056 Appeals Court of Massachusetts, No. 2025-P-0719

Judgment: May 18, 2026

Larry Inoa 28 Lowell St. Lynn, MA 01905 [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presented| QUESTIONS PRESENTED | oe | 1. Whether the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment permits | a state appellate court to deny a self-represented litigant an opportunity to ; — ‘pursue an appeal of a civil-rights action based on late docketing, where the , a petitioner asserts that he timely filed his notice of. appeal and the appellate court | | later issued a notice stating that the failure to enter the appeal timely was | | | informational and did not itself dismiss the appeal. See U.S. Const. amend. XIV, - | § 1; Mass. R. App. P. 3(a)(1), 10. a | _ | | | _- 2. Whether a state court’s application of an excusable-neglect standard toa | | - motion to docket an appeal late may foreclose review of a federal civil-rights claim consistently with the Fourteenth Amendment when the litigant asserts | | _.that the court did not meaningfully consider the circumstances offered to explain , | the delay and the resulting denial of access to appellate review. See U.S. Const. : amend. XIV, § 1; cf. Pioneer Inv. Servs. Co. v. Brunswick Assocs. Ltd. P’ship, 507 | US. 380 (1993). : a |
ifp Todd Aaron Howard Hamilton Sutton, Jr.

v.

United States

26-6057 Eighth Circuit, No. 25-2313

Judgment: August 05, 2026

Heather Rae Quick Federal Public Defender Office - Iowa 222 Third Avenue SE Suite 290 Cedar Rapids, IA 52401 [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presentedQUESTION PRESENTED

Mr. Sutton was arrested for driving while barred and taken to the Cerro Gordo County Jail. The jail has a policy of strip searching every individual charged with a serious misdemeanor! or higher, regardless of whether that individual enters the general population of the jail. Mr. Sutton had money to bond out and had not seen a judicial official, yet was strip searched. It is likely he would never have joined general population; however, during the strip search, officers found methamphetamine. Mr. Sutton’s petition asks the Court to address:

  1. Whether an individual who is unlikely to enter a jail’s general population can be strip searched under a blanket policy requiring strip searches of anyone charged with a misdemeanor or higher?

1 In Iowa, a serious misdemeanor is an offense punishable by a fine of between $430 and $2,560 and up to a year of imprisonment. Iowa Code § 903.1(1)(b). ll

ifp Hatchet M. Speed

v.

United States

26-6058 Fourth Circuit, No. 23-4308

Judgment: May 05, 2026

Carolyn Anne Stewart Stewart Country Law PA 1204 Swilley Rd. Ste B Plant City, FL 33567 [Main Document] [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presentedQUESTIONS PRESENTED FOR REVIEW I. Whether the National Firearm Act’s registration requirements and criminal prohibition on the unregistered possession of silencers (26 U.S.C. §§ 5841, 5861(d)) remain a valid exercise of Congress’s taxing power — or any enumerated power allowing the law to remain Constitutional with continued prosecution of Mr. Speed or anyone — after Congress reduced the making and transfer taxes on silencers to zero dollars.

Petitioner requests a Grant, Vacate, and Remand (GVR) because the issue was not examined at the United States Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals when it issued its Opinion affirming Mr. Speeds’ conviction and intervening factors and a structural change require further review.

II. Whether a full, complete, and unconditional presidential pardon for offenses related to the events of January 6, 2021—effectuated by the Attorney General and Bureau of Prisons through the defendant’s immediate release in the early morning of January 21, 2025— renders the judgment of conviction and any term of supervised release unenforceable, requiring vacatur of the court of appeals’ affirmance when the pardon was not raised below.

Petitioner requests a Grant, Vacate, and Remand (GVR) because the Circuit Court did not examine the issue. The executing authority for the Pardon Proclamation released him from prison before his sentence for his conviction in this case was close to being complete. That executive action effectuated the pardon as to his custody. Probation Services, who works for the Judiciary, told Mr. Speed he was on supervised release, meaning he was still confined with an active sentence. There was encroachment on the Executive Branch and there was no due process, or any process, where no one in the DOJ or its Bureau of Prisons said there had been a mistake in his release.

ifp Sergio Sharrod Hare

v.

Terry Wilkins, Warden

26-6059 Sixth Circuit, No. 25-1518

Judgment: October 17, 2025

Sergio S. Hare #725205 Baraga Correctional Facility 13924 Wadaga Road Baraga, MI 49908 NA
ifp Michael Lavern Boyd

v.

Tiffany M. Williams, Captain, East Arkansas Regional Unit

26-6060 Eighth Circuit, No. 25-2692

Judgment: December 02, 2025

Michael L. Boyd #115890 East Arkansas Regional Unit P.O. Box 970 Marrianna, AR 72360 [Main Document] NA
ifp Zachary Holly

v.

Arkansas

26-6061 Supreme Court of Arkansas, No. CR-24-703

Judgment: April 16, 2026

Anne Elizabeth Fisher Federal Community Defender for the EDPA 601 Walnut Street, The Curtis, Suite 545W Philadelphia, PA 19106 [Main Document] [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presentedCAPITAL CASE QUESTION PRESENTED

In Florida v. Nixon, 543 U.S. 175 (2004), the Court held that the Sixth Amendment does not require counsel to obtain a defendant’s “express consent” to a strategic concession of guilt at a capital trial when that strategy has been “adequately disclosed to and discussed with the defendant” and the defendant does not object to it. Jd. at 179.

In McCoy v. Louisiana, 584 U.S. 414 (2018), the Court held that counsel usurped his client’s autonomy by conceding guilt over the defendant’s “adamant” objections. /d. at 417. Those objections began with McCoy’s “furious” rejection of a concession strategy that counsel discussed with his client two weeks before trial. Id. at 418-19.

In this Arkansas death penalty case, defense counsel conceded the guilt of his cognitively impaired client without first disclosing that strategy to him. The lower courts are divided over whether McCoy or Nixon controls when, as here, a defendant 1s surprised by counsel’s concession of guilt but does not affirmatively object to counsel or the court.

The question presented 1s:

When trial counsel concedes a defendant’s guilt without first consulting the defendant about that strategy, and the defendant does not object at the time of trial, does the lack of an objection prevent the defendant from showing that trial counsel usurped his autonomy under the Sixth Amendment as enforced by McCoy?

1

ifp Sara Hutchinson

v.

Ed Putka

26-6062 Court of Appeals of Washington, Division 2, No. 58844-7-II

Judgment: April 29, 2025

Sara Hutchinson PO Box 773 Kalama, WA 98625 [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presented| Questions Presented | | | 1. State Fair Housing Protection: Whether Washington courts erred in failing to interpret RCW 49.60.2235 — Washington’s fair housing anti-coercion statute — consistently with its | _ federal analogue, 42 U.S.C. § 3617, thereby undermining important housing rights and | protections against coercion and retaliation for protected individuals (specifically disabled veterans and vulnerable persons} in real estate transactions. | | 2. Procedural Due Process: Whether the trial and appellate courts violated Petitioner’s | | _ right to procedural due process by excluding or disregarding material evidence and by | reversing the trial court’s initial summary judgment ruling (which had allowed a | Petitioner’s discrimination claim to proceed) without any material change in circumstances — effectively depriving Petitioner of a fair opportunity to present her case | to a jury. | | | . 3. Equal Protection: Whether the decisions below deny Petitioner the equal protection of | | | _ the laws guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment, where Petitioner — as an honorably discharged veteran with mental health disabilities — was deprived of the protections of | | | state anti-discrimination law intended for her benefit, and whether the lower courts’ | | handling of her claims failed to afford the careful consideration warranted for members | of these protected classes. | |
ifp Paul Shao

v.

Allstate Insurance Company

26-6063 Fourth Circuit, No. 25-2248

Judgment: May 26, 2026

Paul Shao 9233 Lee Masey Drive Lorton, VA 22079 NA
ifp Israel Garcia

v.

United States

26-6064 Second Circuit, No. 24-1673

Judgment: March 25, 2026

Carla Marie Sanderson Carla Sanderson Law 260 Madison Avenue, Floor 22 New York, NY 10016 [Main Document] [Petition] NA
app William Keith Speer

v.

Texas

26A635 Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas, No. WR-59,101-06

Judgment: —

Donna F. Coltharp Fed. Pub. Def. for Western District of Texas 919 Congress Ave Suite 950 Austing, TX 78701 [Main Document] [Lower Court Orders/Opinions] NA
app Carl Gordon

v.

Gavin Newsom, Governor of California

26A636 Ninth Circuit, No. 26-6605

Judgment: —

Carl Gordon 8306 Wilshire Blvd. No. 792 Beverly Hills, CA 90211 [Main Document] NA
app J. Jesus Lopez Jaime

v.

Todd Blanche, Attorney General

26A637 Sixth Circuit, No. 26-3802

Judgment: —

J. Jesus Lopez Jaime North Lake Processing Center 1805 W. 32nd Street Baldwin, MI 49304 NA
app Antron Demond Jackson

v.

Texas

26A638 Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas, No. PD-0570-26

Judgment: —

Antron Demond Jackson #02547298 Barry B. Telford Unit 3899 Highway 98 New Boston, TX 75570 [Main Document] [Lower Court Orders/Opinions] NA
app Entrata, Inc.

v.

Kaitlyn Trimble, Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated

26A639 Fourth Circuit, No. 25-1975

Judgment: —

Jordan Bock Goodwin Procter LLP 100 Northern Avenue Boston, MA 02210 [Main Document] [Lower Court Orders/Opinions] NA
app Rickey Benson

v.

Anthony C. Alexander, Director, Shelby County Division of Corrections

26A640 Sixth Circuit, No. 25-5961

Judgment: —

Rickey Benson #204821 Shelby County Correctional Center 1045 Mullins Station Rd. Memphis, TN 38134 [Main Document] [Lower Court Orders/Opinions] NA
app Rickey Benson

v.

Samuel H. Mays, Jr.

26A641 Sixth Circuit, No. 26-5158

Judgment: —

Rickey Benson #204821 Shelby County Correctional Center 1045 Mullins Station Rd. Memphis, TN 38134 [Main Document] [Lower Court Orders/Opinions] NA
app Rickey Benson

v.

Anthony C. Alexander

26A642 Sixth Circuit, No. 26-5177

Judgment: —

Rickey Benson #204821 Shelby County Correctional Center 1045 Mullins Station Rd. Memphis, TN 38134 [Main Document] [Lower Court Orders/Opinions] NA
app John Anthony Castro

v.

United States

26A643 Fifth Circuit, No. 24-11000, 26-10428

Judgment: —

John Anthony Castro 93890-510 FPC Pollock Camp PO Box 2099 Pollock, LA 71467 [Main Document] [Lower Court Orders/Opinions] NA
app Ebony Taylor

v.

Shirley Weber, California, Secretary of State

26A644 Supreme Court of California, No. S299392

Judgment: —

Ebony Esperanza Taylor PO Box 391 Del Mar, CA 92014 [Main Document] NA