Petitions and applications docketed on November 19, 2026
type Caption Docket No Court Below Petitioner's Counsel Counsel's Address Recent Filings QP
paid City of Daytona Beach, Florida

v.

Dennis Scott

26-654 Eleventh Circuit, No. 24-12662, 24-12964

Judgment: June 25, 2026

Michael H. Kahn MICHAEL KAHN, P.A. 482 N. Harbor City Blvd. Melbourne, FL 32935 [Petition] NA
paid Ricardo Devengoechea

v.

Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela

26-655 Eleventh Circuit, No. 24-10029

Judgment: August 18, 2026

Dennis Grossman Law Office of Dennis Grossman 6701 Sunset Drive, Suite 104 Miami, FL 33143 [Petition] NA
paid National Association of Immigration Judges

v.

Sirce E. Owen, Acting Director of the Executive Office for Immigration Review

26-656 Fourth Circuit, No. No. 23-2235

Judgment: August 19, 2026

Ramya Krishnan Knight First Amendment Inst. at Columbia Univ. 475 riverside Drive , Suite 302 New York, NY 10115 [Petition] NA
paid Matthew John Theiler

v.

United States

26-657 Fifth Circuit, No. 24-40779

Judgment: July 07, 2026

Daniel L. Geyser Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer (US) LLP 2000 K Street, N.W., 4th Fl. Washington, DC 20006 [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presentedQUESTION PRESENTED

This case presents a clear and acknowledged conflict over an important question of federal criminal law.

Under the rule of equipoise, a jury confronted with cir- cumstantial evidence cannot convict based on an inference of guilt where the evidence equally supports a competing inference of innocent behavior. The en bane Fifth Circuit has flatly rejected the equipoise rule (allowing convictions despite equally compelling innocent inferences), whereas the opposite position is “entrenched” in other circuits (dis- allowing convictions in the same circumstances).

In proceedings below, petitioner was convicted of a healtheare-kickback conspiracy based on inferences from circumstantial evidence. Under controlling circuit law, the Fifth Circuit was required to ignore the competing inno- cent inferences from each key piece of evidence. Had the prosecution instead arisen in the First, Sixth, Seventh, Eighth, Tenth, or Eleventh Circuits, the innocent infer- ences would have been considered and petitioner’s convic- tion presumably would have been reversed.

The question presented is:

Whether, when the evidence gives equal circumstan- tial support to a theory of guilt and a theory of innocence, courts must reverse because a rational jury would neces- sarily entertain reasonable doubt.

(I)

ifp Anibal Muniz

v.

Richard Comerford, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections

26-6188 Eleventh Circuit, No. 25-14476

Judgment: July 31, 2026

Dane Kristofor Chase Chase Law Florida P.A. 111 2nd Ave NE., Suite 334 Saint Petersburg, FL 33701 [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presentedQUESTION PRESENTED Whether the Sixth Amendment requires defense counsel to offer a criminal defendant his informed opinion as to what plea should be entered? |
ifp Johnny Bedgood, Jr.

v.

Waste Management, Inc.

26-6189 Eleventh Circuit, No. 25-12372

Judgment: June 22, 2026

Johnny Bedgood Jr. 442 Oldenberg St. SW Palm Bay, FL 32908 [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presentedQUESTIONS PRESENTED 1. Whether, under 42 U.S.C. § 12112(b)(5)(A), an employee must make a new, specific request for additional accommodation when the employer already knows of the employee's disability and need for accommodation and is participating in an ongoing medical-leave and return-to-work process, or whether existing knowledge and contextual communications may suffice to trigger the employer's continuing accommodation obligations. 2. Whether Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56 permits a court to treat an employer's disputed account of medical-leave expiration, return-to-work authorization, and attendance-related termination as established, despite contemporaneous medical and leave-administration records supporting contrary reasonable inferences, consistent with Jolan v. Cotton, 572 U.S. 650 (2014), and Reeves v. Sanderson Plumbing Products, Inc., 530 U.S. 133 (2000). 3. Whether Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 26, 37, and 56 permit a district court to grant summary judgment on an independently dispositive employer-identity determination by relying on a corporate declaration first introduced after discovery closed, without adequately addressing disclosure compliance, the plaintiff's opportunity to challenge the declaration, and genuinely disputed evidence of corporate employment control, where the plaintiff contested that determination and the court of appeals affirmed on alternative grounds without expressly resolving the employer-identity issue. 4. Whether the Fifth Amendment’s guarantee of a meaningful opportunity to be heard is implicated when a federal court of appeals affirms summary judgment based on disputed characterizations of medical-leave and return-to-work records, and subsequently denies rehearing after the appellant specifically identifies overlooked material evidence and Rule 56 objections.
ifp Antonio Urena Infante

v.

Jennifer Mendoza

26-6190 Court of Appeal of California, Second Appellate District, No. B340296

Judgment: May 12, 2026

Antonio Urena Infante 1309 Speers Ave San Mateo, CA 94403 [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presented: | oe QUESTIONS PRESENTED | | ~ California Family Code § 6306(a)(1) provides that, before issuing or denying a | _ domestic violence restraining order, the trial court "shall ensure" that a criminal-

_ history database search is conducted to determine whether the respondent has prior : violent or serious felony convictions, specified domestic-violence offenses, . | outstanding warrants, firearm-related disqualifications, or prior restraining-order |

violations. , | | | | The California Court of Appeal held that although the record did not indicate

  • whether the mandatory statutory search was conducted, any failure to comply with

| the statute was harmless because the court believed the outcome would likely have 7 been the same. | | | ; | | | The Questions Presented are: | 7 |

  1. Whether the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment permits a | | | state court to disregard a mandatory state-created procedural safeguard | | | enacted to ensure accurate adjudication of proceedings affecting substantial | liberty interests, including firearm rights, parental rights, and personal | liberty. | | |
  2. Whether a state court may employ harmless-error review to excuse | 7 noncompliance with a mandatory statutory verification procedure specifically | enacted to reduce the risk of erroneous factual determinations in proceedings . |
ifp Jan Elizabeth Lightfoot, aka Jan Christopher, aka Janice Marie Banks

v.

Oak Bend Medical Center

26-6191 Fifth Circuit, No. 26-20056

Judgment: August 07, 2026

Jan Elizabeth Lightfoot 12319 Chesterbrook Drive Houston, TX 77031 [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presentedQuestions Presented | |

Question 1: A Different Controversy Adjudicated |

Whether Article III, the First Amendment right of access to the courts, and the Fifth and Fourteenth

Amendments permit a federal court to dismiss an action after evaluating a controversy materially

different from the one pleaded, thereby leaving the pleaded claims, parties, records, legal theories,

and requested relief unaddressed. :

Question 2: Stigma-Plus / Constitutional Protection Question

Whether the accusation, perception, presumption, or classification of mental instability may be |

used to diminish or extinguish a citizen’s rights to due process of law, equal protection of the laws,

personal safety, bodily autonomy, protected property interests, credibility, voice, and meaningful

access to the courts. |

Question 3: ROA / Due Process / Record-Refutation Question

Whether due process of law and meaningful access to the courts are denied when official

governmental records, agency adjudications, sworn affidavits, and documentary evidence

contained in the Record on Appeal materially refute the factual premises relied upon by opposing

parties and accepted by the lower courts, yet the courts fail to reconcile those records, address their

legal effect, or adjudicate the claims supported by them pursuant to their constitutional obligations

before dismissing the action as conclusory, non-cognizable, frivolous, or facially implausible.

Question 4: Liberty Loss Without Judicial Determination

Whether the Fourteenth Amendment and the liberty principles recognized in O’Connor v.

Donaldson, supra, 422 U.S. 563 (1975), permit federal courts to dismiss, sustain, or affirm an

involuntary deprivation of liberty where no judge at any level of government made a judicial | i

ifp David Paul Martinez

v.

United States

26-6192 Ninth Circuit, No. 23-432

Judgment: March 18, 2026

Jeffrey T. Green Green Lauerman Chartered P.L.L.C. 1050 30th Street NW Washington, DC 20007 [Main Document] [Lower Court Orders/Opinions] [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presentedQUESTION PRESENTED Whether 18 U.S.C. § 922(¢)(9)’s permanent, lifetime ban on firearm possession by domestic violence misde- meanants 1s unconstitutional as applied to individuals whose misdemeanor conviction involved nonviolent conduct? (1)
ifp John Anaya

v.

Napa County, California

26-6193 Fourth Circuit, No. 26-1415

Judgment: September 29, 2026

John Anaya P.O. Box 17 Thornburg, VA 22565 NA
ifp Ernest Emory Dublin, Jr.

v.

Nicole L. Ayers

26-6194 District Court of Appeals of Florida, Sixth District, No. 6D2026-1251

Judgment: June 05, 2026

Ernest Emory Dublin Jr. 1472 Old Apopka Road Apopka, FL 32703 NA
ifp C. H.

v.

Ch. H.

26-6195 Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division, No. A-0773-24

Judgment: March 19, 2026

Michael James Confusione Hegge & Confusione P.O. Box 366 Mullica, NJ 08062 [Petition] [Appendix]
Question(s) presentedQUESTIONS PRESENTED

Petitioners, a mother and her minor daughter, alleged that private actors— working in concert with New Jersey’s child-protection agency—deliberately fabricated an accusation of Munchausen syndrome by proxy that launched nearly two years of state abuse-and-neglect proceedings against their family, which the State ultimately abandoned. They alleged that this conduct violated their rights under the Fourteenth Amendment. Before any discovery, the New Jersey courts dismissed every claim with prejudice—the trial court holding the reporting physician entitled to “absolute immunity” under a state statute “whether or not the reporter acted with malice,” holding the agency’s retained psychologist protected by the state litigation privilege and “judicial immunity,” and holding petitioners’ relative, as a private citizen, “incapable of taking ‘state action.” In doing so, the courts found that the record showed “good faith,” “reasonable cause,” and no “evidence” of malice.

The questions presented are:

  1. Whether, consistent with the Supremacy Clause and this Court’s decisions in Martinez v. California, 444 U.S. 277 (1980), Howlett v. Rose, 496 U.S. 356 (1990), and Doe v. Dynamic Physical Therapy, LLC, 607 U.S. 11 (2025) (per curiam), a state court may apply state-law immunities and privileges—and a categorical rule that private persons cannot act under color of law—to dismiss claims that defendants deliberately fabricated child-abuse accusations to procure state proceedings in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment.

  2. Whether the Due Process Clause permits a state court to extinguish a plaintiffs pleaded causes of action on a motion to dismiss by finding, from materials outside the complaint and before any discovery, that the defendants acted in good faith and without malice.

1

ifp Kenneth Wayne Lancaster

v.

Oregon

26-6196 Court of Appeals of Oregon, No. A178488

Judgment: November 26, 2025

Kenneth Wayne Lancaster #8523240 Two Rivers Correctional Institution 82911 Beach Access Road Umatilla, OR 97882 [Main Document] [Lower Court Orders/Opinions] NA
app SVB Financial Trust

v.

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, as Receiver for Silicon Valley Bank and Silicon Valley Bridge Bank, N.A.

26A717 Second Circuit, No. 25-567

Judgment: —

Gregory George Garre Latham & Watkins LLP 555 Eleventh Street, NW Suite 1000 Washington, DC 20004 [Main Document] NA
app Amy Pomeroy

v.

Utah State Bar

26A718 Tenth Circuit, No. 24-4054

Judgment: —

Scott Day Freeman Goldwater Institute 500 E. Coronado Rd. Phoenix, AZ 85004 [Main Document] NA
app Rinnai America Corporation

v.

South Coast Air Quality Management District

26A719 Ninth Circuit, No. 25-5129

Judgment: —

Sarah O'Beirne Jorgensen Reichman Jorgensen Lehman & Feldberg LLP 1899 L Street, NW, Suite 410 Washington, DC 20036 [Main Document] NA
app Union Pacific Railroad Company

v.

Surface Transportation Board

26A720 Eighth Circuit, No. 25-2919

Judgment: —

Tobias Samuel Loss-Eaton Sidley Austin LLP 1501 K Street NW Washington, DC 20005 [Main Document] [Lower Court Orders/Opinions] NA
app Derrick Lee Smith

v.

Michigan State Police

26A722 Sixth Circuit, No. 26-1486

Judgment: —

Derrick Lee Smith #267009-A-119 Alger CF N6141 Industrial Park Dr Munsing, MI 49862 [Main Document] NA